Raw Milk Near Water Mill, NY
28 local raw milk sources available
Search the database to find raw milk
Designed and coded from scratch. The same developer builds MVPs, internal business systems, and writes about it.
Support GetRawMilk.com
Mapping raw milk sources by hand since 2018.
Tips keep it free and updated daily.
Select a tip amount
Enter an amount of $1 or more.
✓ You're supporting a free community resource. This is a tip/donation, not a purchase of milk or products.
Raw Milk Availability in Water Mill, NY
Within 50 miles of Water Mill, NY, we found 5 farms offering direct sales and 23 off-farm sources including stores, drop points, and delivery services.
Available Products
27 places to find cow milk, 1 place to find A2 cow milk, 1 place to find goat milk, 1 place to find sheep milk, 1 place to find buffalo milk, 1 place to find camel milk, 1 place to find cow milk kefir, and 1 place to find goat milk kefir.
Raw Milk Farms, Retailers & Pickup Locations Near Water Mill, NY
Raw Milk Sources in Water Mill, NY
-
Mecox Bay Dairy
855 Mecox Road
Water Mill, NY
US 11976Dairy farm in Bridgehampton, New York on the south shore of Long Island selling fresh dairy.View Mecox Bay Dairy's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Water Mill, NY.
Mecox Bay Dairy -
Ty Llwyd Farm
5793 Sound Ave
Riverhead, NY
US 11901-5611Raw milk farm on the north shore of Long Island. The farm also has fresh eggs for sale.View Ty Llwyd Farm's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Riverhead, NY.
Ty Llwyd Farm -
Udder Milk Farm - Home Delivery Suffolk County
Contact for details
Suffolk County, NY
USView Udder Milk Farm - Home Delivery Suffolk County's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Suffolk County, NY.
Udder Milk Farm - Home Delivery Suffolk County -
FoodWorks
940 Boston Post Rd
Old Saybrook, CT
US 06475-2128View FoodWorks's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Old Saybrook, CT.
FoodWorks -
Coffees Country Market
169 Boston Post Road
Old Lyme, CT
US 06371View Coffees Country Market's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Old Lyme, CT.
Coffees Country Market -
Foodworks
450 Boston Post Rd, 102
Guilford, CT
US 06437-2933View Foodworks's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Guilford, CT.
Foodworks -
Bishop's Orchards Farm Market & Winery
1355 Boston Post Road
Guilford, CT
US 06437View Bishop's Orchards Farm Market & Winery's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Guilford, CT.
Bishop's Orchards Farm Market & Winery -
Tri-Town Foods
15 Chesterfield Road
East Lyme, CT
US 06333View Tri-Town Foods's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in East Lyme, CT.
Tri-Town Foods -
Adams Hometown Market
193 Main Street
Deep River, CT
US 06417View Adams Hometown Market's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Deep River, CT.
Adams Hometown Market -
Fiddleheads Food Co-op
13 Broad St
New London, CT
US 06320-5901View Fiddleheads Food Co-op's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in New London, CT.
Fiddleheads Food Co-op -
Four Seasons Market LLC
875 W Main St
Branford, CT
US 06405-3425View Four Seasons Market LLC's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Branford, CT.
Four Seasons Market LLC -
River Valley Provisions
95 Bridge Road
Haddam, CT
US 06438View River Valley Provisions's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Haddam, CT.
River Valley Provisions -
McQuade's Marketplace
14 Clara Drive
Stonington, CT
US 06355View McQuade's Marketplace's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Stonington, CT.
McQuade's Marketplace -
Salem Prime Cuts
12 New London Road
Salem, CT
US 06420View Salem Prime Cuts's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Salem, CT.
Salem Prime Cuts -
Herb's Country Deli & Restaurant
1115 Norwich-New London Turnpike
Montville, CT
US 06382View Herb's Country Deli & Restaurant's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Montville, CT.
Herb's Country Deli & Restaurant -
Provisions on State
981 State Street
New Haven, CT
US 06511View Provisions on State's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in New Haven, CT.
Provisions on State -
Elm City Market
777 Chapel Street
New Haven, CT
US 06510View Elm City Market's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in New Haven, CT.
Elm City Market -
P&M Orange Street Market
721 Orange Street
New Haven, CT
US 06511View P&M Orange Street Market's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in New Haven, CT.
P&M Orange Street Market -
Edge of the Woods Market
379 Whalley Ave
New Haven, CT
US 06511-3044View Edge of the Woods Market's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in New Haven, CT.
Edge of the Woods Market -
Deerfield Farm
337 Parmelee Hill Rd
Durham, CT
US 06422-2630View Deerfield Farm's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Durham, CT.
Deerfield Farm -
Ginger Root Health Food Store
205 W Thames St
Norwich, CT
US 06360-6838View Ginger Root Health Food Store's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Norwich, CT.
Ginger Root Health Food Store -
Westchester MarketPlace
493 Westchester Road
Colchester, CT
US 06415View Westchester MarketPlace's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Colchester, CT.
Westchester MarketPlace -
Thyme & Season
3040 Whitney Avenue
Hamden, CT
US 06518Health Food - Supplements - Natural & Organic - Local Products - Hours: Mon-Fri 8am-7pm Sat: 9am-7pm Sun: 10am-6pmView Thyme & Season's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Hamden, CT.
Thyme & Season -
Nature’s Way
922 Barnum Avenue Cutoff
Stratford, CT
US 06614Health food store, offers a subscription for raw milk. Milk is sourced from Baldwin Brook Farm in CT.View Nature’s Way's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Stratford, CT.
Nature’s Way -
Noel's IGA Supermarket
15 Broadway Street
Colchester, CT
US 06415View Noel's IGA Supermarket's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Colchester, CT.
Noel's IGA Supermarket -
Brush Hill Dairy, LLC
87 Brush Hill Rd
Bozrah, CT
US 06334-1100View Brush Hill Dairy, LLC's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Bozrah, CT.
Brush Hill Dairy, LLC -
It's Only Natural Market
575 Main Street
Middletown, CT
US 06457Retail Grocery, sells locally produced Raw Milk from Baldwin Brook Farms in CT.View It's Only Natural Market's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Middletown, CT.
It's Only Natural Market -
Buttercup Dairy
20 Nygren Road
Lisbon, CT
US 06351View Buttercup Dairy's location, social media, contact info, and all other info added to the map in Lisbon, CT.
Buttercup Dairy
Find raw milk by species
Find other raw milk products
Find farm meat & eggs
Other ways to find raw milk
Swipe right on some shirts
Contribute
Your support covers hosting, development, and the daily work of keeping listings updated.
-
Submit a new listing ＋Add a farm to the database
-
SponsorshipsOngoing support with visibility
-
Buy me a milk 🥛Leave a one-time tip
Latest Blog Posts
-
Can Ranchers Now Sell Beef Without USDA Inspection?
Two executive orders signed September 4, 2026 do not let ranchers sell uninspected beef. What they actually direct, and the labeling review that matters more.
-
Where Does American Ground Beef Come From? What the Label Doesn’t Say
Most US ground beef blends imported lean trim with domestic fat, and carries no origin label. How the rules work, and how to find beef you can trace.
-
How the Parent Company Behind Cabot Cheese Barred a Farm From Selling Raw Milk
Agri-Mark, the dairy processor behind Cabot cheese, told a raw milk farm in Warren, Massachusetts to stop direct sales or leave.
-
The 2026 Cyclospora Outbreak: Six Clusters, One Named Source
Federal investigators are tracking six Cyclospora outbreaks this summer. Only one has a named supplier, and even that wasn’t confirmed by a lab test.
-
Why Raw Milk Outbreaks Are Traced Faster Than Produce Outbreaks
Two federal surveillance studies spanning two decades show raw milk outbreaks get traced to a single farm within days, while most produce outbreaks never are.
-
Canada’s Raw Milk Legalization Push Builds Toward October 2026 Review
The federal ban on raw milk sale remains in place, though organized advocacy for a licensed pathway is building toward an independent review this October.